Black Friday-20%BLACKFRIDAY20until 29 Nov
← Back to the blog

The second visit: the most important moment in any loyalty program

The customer who picked up your card today is not a regular yet. Here is why the second visit decides most of it, and how to make it easy.

The second visit: the most important moment in any loyalty program

Most business owners judge a loyalty program by how many cards they have handed out. Sign-ups are only the beginning, though. A customer who took your card and never came back is not a member. They are a name on a list.

Why the second time matters so much

The first visit can be chance: the customer was in the neighbourhood, had a few minutes to spare, or a friend recommended you. The second visit is a choice. Once someone comes back, a habit starts to form, and habits are what keep a customer for years.

That is why the first few weeks after sign-up are the most fragile period. The longer a customer goes without a second visit, the lower the odds you will see them again.

Make the first reward feel close

A card with ten empty stamps looks like a long road. A few moves that bring the goal closer:

  • Add the first stamp straight away, with the purchase during which the customer got the card, so they never start from zero.

  • Choose a shorter card, say 6 stamps instead of 10, and scale the reward to match.

  • Explain at the till, in one sentence, what the customer earns and when.

Remind customers that you exist

A card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet has one big advantage over a paper one: you can send a notification straight to the customer's lock screen. A short message a few days after the first visit is often enough to bring them back.

Keep it simple and warm. For example: "Lovely to meet you! We are saving your second stamp for you." A message like that does not read as an advert. It reads as an invitation.

Use the welcome message too. It reaches the customer the moment they add the card to their phone, which makes it your first contact with them and the best time to tell them what to expect.

What to keep an eye on

Do not look only at the number of new cards. Ask yourself: of the people who signed up last month, how many came back? That number says far more about the health of your program than any sign-up total.

A good sign-up brings a customer in once. A good program brings them back a second time. After that, habit does the work.

Share this article

Get in Touch

Interested? Leave your details

Leave your email or phone number and we'll get back to you, or call you to show how it works.