Stamps, points, discount or membership: which program fits your business?
Not every loyalty program works for every business. A practical guide to choosing between a stamp card, points, a fixed discount and a membership.

The first question every business asks before starting a loyalty program is "what should I give away?". The right question is a different one: how do your customers buy? The answer to that almost always tells you which program fits.
Stamp card: for frequent, similar purchases
The classic "collect 8, get 1 free" card works best when customers often buy something at a similar price: coffee, pastries, a haircut, a car wash.
It is the easiest to understand. Customers see at a glance how far they are from the reward.
Progress shows on the card, and every new stamp is a small win.
The reward should have real value, but cost only a small share of the revenue from the visits it takes the customer to earn it.
Points: when the basket changes from one purchase to the next
If a customer spends €5 one time and €60 the next, one stamp per visit is fair to neither of you. Points reward customers in proportion to what they spend.
They suit retail shops, wine shops, florists and restaurants with a wide price range.
You can set several rewards, at different point levels.
They need a little more explaining at the till, so keep the rules simple.
Fixed discount: for an immediate, everyday benefit
With this program the card shows a fixed discount percentage, applied on every visit. No waiting, no coupons.
It suits businesses with regulars, such as a neighbourhood tavern or a shop with a loyal local crowd.
It is simple, but it gives customers no reason to come more often, only to choose you over the place next door.
Work out the percentage carefully, because you give it on every purchase.
Membership: for long-term relationships
The membership card shows the customer's tier and when their membership expires, and every visit is recorded.
It suits gyms, dance schools, beauty salons and any service sold on a monthly or yearly subscription.
Tiers, for example Silver and Gold, give customers a reason to move up.
The card on the phone replaces the plastic membership card that gets lost or left at home.
A quick rule of thumb
Frequent purchases at a similar price: stamps.
Purchases that vary a lot in value: points.
You want to reward regulars without much explaining: fixed discount.
You sell subscriptions: membership.
Whatever you choose, what matters most is that customers understand the card at first glance. A simple program you can explain in ten seconds will always beat a clever one that needs instructions.



